I also loved Beowulf, the story, characters and mood. I didn't really expect to, but I gave it a chance and was easily drawn into it. I liked it so much that I watched it again a few days later. (That for me is pretty high praise as I love suspense and once I know what happens, I don't want to see again unless it was that good it is worth reliving without the edge).

Other movies that are repeaters is (probably my favourite) "Election" with Matthew Broderick and Reece Witherspoon. Just so clever and funny and my taste in humour I guess.

Back in the late 90's "Fargo" was a movie I watched several times. Same with "The Talented Mr. Ripley".

Oh, and "Ground Hog Day". Maybe that is the bigger fav. I've watched that a ridiculous amount of times and still love it and would watch it again if I caught it on TV.